Would a cell phone work on a submerged submarine?

By: Beth Brindle

No one's going to be making cell phone calls from a submarine anytime soon.
No one's going to be making cell phone calls from a submarine anytime soon.
Stocktrek Images/Thinkstock

"Can you hear me? Can you hear me now?" If you're trying to use your cell phone on a submerged submarine, the answer is no.

Cell phone signals use very high frequency radio waves (around 800 or 1900 megahertz in the United States). They travel in a straight line, are extremely susceptible to interference and break apart as soon as they encounter salty seawater.


Even above the ocean's surface, a submarine would need to be pretty close to shore because cell phones rely on a network of base stations, or cell phone towers, to transmit signals. In theory, a cell phone might be able to communicate with a tower as far as 45 miles (72 kilometers) away, but a signal at this distance would be far from reliable; a range of just a few miles is more typical [source: Markgraf].

Submarines must stay submerged at a depth of about 200 to 330 feet (60 to 100 meters) in order to avoid detection [source: Baker]. For decades, submerged submarines have communicated only through extremely low frequency (ELF) or very low frequency (VLF) radio waves because signals in these very low ranges (300 hertz to 30 kilohertz) are able to travel long distances and penetrate seawater [sources: GlobalSecurity, Stanford University].

But ELF and VLF have extremely limited bandwidth, with data transfer rates ranging from a few hundred bits per second to as low as a few bits per minute. To get reception, submarines must tow large antenna cables and reduce their speed underwater.

In recent years, the U.S. Navy has explored new technologies, such as small communication buoys that can be launched to the surface to establish a connection with military satellites and quantum key distribution, which seeks to use the principles of quantum mechanics to communicate securely with submerged subs [sources: Baker, Edwards].


ElectronicsCell PhonesHow Cell Phones WorkElectronicsCell PhonesCan cell phones make you sterile?ElectronicsCell PhonesCell Phone PicturesElectronicsCell PhonesHow Cell Phone Jammers WorkElectronicsCell PhonesWhich cell phone should I buy for my grandmother?ElectronicsCell PhonesInside a Cell PhoneElectronicsTravel GadgetsIntroduction to Global Cell PhonesElectronicsCell PhonesHow are cell phones cloned?ElectronicsCell PhonesHow Prepaid Cell Phones WorkElectronicsCell PhonesCan you charge your cell phone with a fuel cell?ElectronicsCell PhonesTop 5 Future Cell PhonesElectronicsCell PhonesHow do I use my cell phone as a modem?ElectronicsCell PhonesIntroduction to How Video Conferencing Cell Phones WorkElectronicsCell Phones5 Ways to Donate Your Old Smartphone or Cell Phone to CharityElectronicsCell PhonesCell Phone Tower PicturesElectronicsCell PhonesHow Much Radiation Does Your Cell Phone Emit?ElectronicsHow-to TechHow to Unlock a Cell Phone or SmartphoneElectronicsCell PhonesCan extreme weather damage your cell phone?ElectronicsTravel GadgetsHow Wind-up Cell Phone Chargers WorkElectronicsCell PhonesHow to Tether a Cell PhoneElectronicsCell PhonesHow did digital technology change cell phone service?ElectronicsCell PhonesHow to Unlock an Android Cell PhoneElectronicsCell PhonesScientists Have Invented a Battery-free Cell PhoneElectronicsCell PhonesHow to Decide Between a Smart Phone and Cell PhoneElectronicsTelephone TechnologyHow to Forward Calls from a Landline to a Cell PhoneElectronicsCell PhonesHow to Import Pictures from a Cell Phone to a LaptopElectronicsTech's Effects on the Family5 Ways to Keep Your Kids Off Their Cell PhonesElectronicsTech for KidsCell Phones for Kids: When is the right time?ElectronicsCell PhonesWould a cell phone work on a submerged submarine?ElectronicsCell PhonesHow to Transfer Data from One Cell Phone to AnotherElectronicsCell PhonesCan you use a cell phone as a credit card?ElectronicsCell PhonesWhy is a cell phone called a cell phone?ElectronicsCell PhonesElectromagnetic InterferenceElectronicsCell PhonesWhat does GSM mean in a cell phone?ElectronicsCell PhonesHow does a vibrating cell phone or pager work?ElectronicsCell PhonesHow GPS Phones WorkElectronicsHow-to TechHow to Unlock GSM PhonesElectronicsCell PhonesHow Smartphones WorkElectronicsCell PhonesCell-phone CodesElectronicsCell PhonesCell-phone Frequencies - Cell phone FrequenciesElectronicsCell Phone AppsHow to Fake a GPS Location on Your PhoneElectronicsWirelessHow 5G WorksElectronicsTelephone TechnologyWhy does the phone still work when the electricity goes out?ElectronicsCell PhonesHow Cell-phone Radiation WorksElectronicsCell PhonesHow Cell-phone Viruses WorkElectronicsCell PhonesHow Cell-phone Implants WorkElectronicsHigh-Tech Gadgets5 Tips for Picking the Right SmartphoneElectronicsCell PhonesCell-phone Network Technologies: 3G - 3G Cell phonesElectronicsCell PhonesInside a Digital Cell PhoneElectronicsWirelessHow 4G WorksElectronicsCell PhonesDo Smartphones Really Charge Faster in Airplane Mode?ElectronicsCell Phones4 Reasons Your Phone Keeps Dropping CallsElectronicsCell PhonesPotential Health Risks - How Cell-phone Radiation WorksElectronicsCell PhonesSmartphone Hardware and Software - How Smartphones WorkElectronicsCell PhonesCell-phone Channels - Cell phone ChannelsElectronicsCell PhonesSource of Radiation - How Cell-phone Radiation WorksElectronicsCell PhonesCell Phone Jamming DeviceElectronicsCell PhonesAnalog Cell PhonesElectronicsFuture TechWhat Will Replace the Smartphone?ElectronicsWirelessHow WiFi Phones WorkElectronicsTelephone TechnologyDo smartphone covers really protect phones from damage?ElectronicsCell PhonesCell Phone Jamming Legal IssuesElectronicsCell PhonesCell Phone Network Technologies: 2G - 2G Cell phone NetworksElectronicsCell PhonesCell Phone Jamming BasicsElectronicsCell PhonesGSM and CDMA - How Cell Phones WorkElectronicsCell PhonesCould someone stalk you using your own smartphone?ElectronicsCell Phones6 Creative Uses for an Old SmartphoneElectronicsTravel GadgetsIntroduction to Global Cell Phones

Lots More Information

Related Articles

  • Baker, Berenice. "Deep secret – secure submarine communication on a quantum level." Naval-technology.com. Dec. 6, 2013. (Aug. 10, 2014) http://www.naval-technology.com/features/featuredeep-secret-secure-submarine-communication-on-a-quantum-level/
  • Edwards, Lin. "New buoys enable submerged subs to communicate." Phys.org. July 13, 2010. (Aug. 10, 2014) http://phys.org/news198219967.html
  • GlobalSecurity.org. "Submarine Communications." July 7, 2011. (Aug. 10, 2014) http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/ship/sub-comm.htm
  • Markgraf, Bert. "How Far Can a Cell Tower Be for a Cell Phone to Pick Up the Signal?" Houston Chronicle. (Aug. 10, 2014) http://smallbusiness.chron.com/far-can-cell-tower-cellphone-pick-up-signal-32124.html
  • Singh, H.B. and Rajendra Pal. "Submarine Communications." Defence Science Journal, Vol. 43, No. 1, pp 43-51. Jan. 1993. (Aug. 10, 2014) http://www.publications.drdo.gov.in/ojs/index.php/dsj/article/download/4209/2463
  • Stanford VLF Group. "Introduction to VLF." (Aug. 10, 2014) http://vlf.stanford.edu/research/introduction-vlf